Uttarakhand High Court
For assessee
Case-law directory
Every ruling, in plain sight.
Search and filter tax rulings from the Supreme Court, the High Courts, the GST Appellate Tribunal and the advance-ruling authorities.
Case-law directory
Search and filter tax rulings from the Supreme Court, the High Courts, the GST Appellate Tribunal and the advance-ruling authorities.
26 rulings found
Uttarakhand High Court
Where department cancelled assessee’s registration based on a show cause notice and order containing only generic allegations of fraud, misstatement or suppression of facts without disclosing factual particulars, denial of material details violated natural justice, making such cancellation unsustainable and liable to be quashed
Chhattisgarh High Court
Where GST registration was cancelled for non-operation from declared place of business based on a show-cause notice omitting specification of date and time for personal hearing as per Form GST REG-17, such omission breached natural justice, rendering notice and cancellation order invalid despite availability of alternative remedy, thus both were quashed with liberty to proceed afresh per law
Punjab & Haryana High Court
Where petitioner’s GST registration was cancelled with retrospective effect based on SCN that did not propose retrospective cancellation, such cancellation exceeded scope of SCN and was unsustainable, thus SCN and cancellation order were quashed, with liberty to authorities to issue fresh SCN and proceed in accordance with law, without further adjudication on merits
Allahabad High Court
Where GST-registered person's registration was cancelled by a non-speaking order with no reasons or recorded satisfaction, such cancellation violated Article 14 and principles of natural justice and was unsustainable, therefore cancellation and consequential appellate order were quashed and matter was revived for fresh adjudication after giving opportunity of hearing to petitioner
Patna High Court
Where registration of works contractor was cancelled for non-filing of returns without affording personal hearing and SCN for revocation lacked officer identity and mandatory DIN, such cancellation and consequent rejection order were invalid, statutory mandate of hearing was not followed, appellate orders suffered from jurisdictional error, so impugned orders were set aside and registration directed to be restored GST: Where petitioner filed updated returns and paid late fee before revocation SCN, but SCN lacked officer name, designation and DIN and did not consider earlier communications regarding illness and son’s murder, such non- application of mind and procedural illegality rendered cancellation, revocation rejection and appellate orders unsustainable and registration was directed to be restored with costs, as later circular could not cure these defects retrospectively
Gauhati High Court
Where petitioners challenged show cause notice for cancellation of GST registration on ground that notice was vague and did not specify statutory provisions or rules allegedly violated, such foundational notice lacking material particulars was unsustainable in law and therefore set aside, without precluding authorities from initiating fresh action as per CGST Act and Rules upon proven infraction
Patna High Court
Where assessee's registration was cancelled based solely on uploading of show cause notice on GST portal without service by e-mail or registered post or personal hearing, portal upload was insufficient for valid service, and settled law required personal service by prescribed modes, making cancellation order invalid and requiring re-issuance of SCN with opportunity for hearing and reasoned decision
Punjab & Haryana High Court
Where registered person's GST registration was cancelled with retrospective effect from 1 May 2023 though SCN did not propose such retrospective cancellation, such order was not sustainable and had to be quashed in view of relevant precedents, with liberty to authorities to issue fresh SCN and proceed as per law
Telangana High Court
Where registration was cancelled for non-furnishing of returns though SCN alleged fraud, such cancellation was invalid as order rested on a ground not mentioned in SCN, breaching requirement to specify precise grounds with material, therefore SCN and cancellation order were quashed and GST registration was restored, with liberty to issue fresh SCN on proper grounds with supporting documents
Himachal Pradesh High Court
Where order dated 17.01.2025 cancelled registration retrospectively from 15.03.2022 without recording reasons for such retrospectivity in SCN or order, even though material showed no functioning unit at declared premises, retrospective cancellation was to be set aside and petitioner was entitled to a fresh reasoned decision on effective date, with actions post 17.01.2025 remaining intact
Telangana High Court
Where registered person was issued notice for cancellation of registration citing fraud, bogus invoicing, and not operating from declared place, but the registration was cancelled on unrelated ground of non-filing of six returns without any notice for same, such cancellation was unsustainable as it violated principles of notice and fair hearing, and registration was restored with liberty to respondent to issue fresh SCN
Bombay High Court
Where GST-registered company’s registration was cancelled for non-filing of GSTR-3B despite no allegation of fraud or intentional default, and petitioner undertook to pay all outstanding GST with interest, late fee and penalty, registration was to be restored upon such payment, failing which petition would stand dismissed
Gauhati High Court
Where registration of a rice mill company was cancelled by a non-speaking order based on a show cause notice failing to specify months or relevant period of default, with no reasons recorded for cancellation and without providing an effective opportunity of hearing, such order violated principles of natural justice and thus same was to be held illegal, warranting restoration to show cause notice stage for fresh proceedings in accordance with law
Gauhati High Court
GST registration cannot be cancelled for non-filing of returns on basis of a vague show cause notice lacking specific period of return default and absence of reasons;cancellation was to be quashed and matter remanded to show cause stage
Gauhati High Court
Where registration of petitioner providing vehicles on hire was cancelled for non-filing of returns based on a show-cause notice lacking details of default period and an order devoid of specific reasons, such non-speaking cancellation order violated statutory mandate and natural justice, warranting quashing and remand for fresh consideration, as adverse civil consequences necessitate reasoned decision
Karnataka High Court
Where registered person’s registration was cancelled based on a vague SCN lacking specific material particulars and authority ignored petitioner’s filed reply, such cancellation was unsustainable as it violated Rule 22 requiring detailed grounds and effective opportunity to respond; thus SCN and cancellation were to be quashed with liberty for fresh proceedings as per law
Karnataka High Court
Where cancellation of registrations was based on SCNs issued under Rule 22(1) resting on defective or blank inspection reports, condition precedent for issuing SCN was not met, hence cancellation orders and consequential suspension were TO be quashed and proceedings were to be restored to SCN stage allowing petitioners to respond with relevant documents
Gauhati High Court
Where registration was cancelled for non-filing of returns for six months and petitioner cited financial hardship while expressing readiness to comply with proviso to Rule 22(4), restoration relief was warranted, with restoration subject to compliance, fresh limitation to run from this order, and petitioner remaining liable for all outstanding tax, interest, penalty and late fee
Gauhati High Court
Where GST registration of a proprietorship was cancelled due to non-filing of returns for six months, petitioner was permitted to seek restoration by filing pending returns and paying tax, interest, penalty, and late fee as per Rule 22(4), upon which authority must consider and restore registration expeditiously, with statutory limitation to run from date of this order
Gauhati High Court
Where registered proprietorship's GST registration was cancelled due to non-filing of returns and non-response to notice after suspension, restoration may be sought by furnishing all pending returns and paying outstanding tax, interest, penalty and late fee, and upon such compliance, authority shall consider restoration as per applicable rules and directions