Madras High Court
For assessee
Case-law directory
Every ruling, in plain sight.
Search and filter tax rulings from the Supreme Court, the High Courts, the GST Appellate Tribunal and the advance-ruling authorities.
Case-law directory
Search and filter tax rulings from the Supreme Court, the High Courts, the GST Appellate Tribunal and the advance-ruling authorities.
50 rulings found
Madras High Court
Where petitioner challenged cancellation of GST registration and both sides agreed issue was covered by Tvl. Suguna Cutpiece Center v. Appellate Deputy (Madras), cancellation was set aside and registration directed to be restored subject to petitioner filing all pending pre-cancellation returns and making related payments in cash, with ITC adjustment not permitted unless approved by department and restoration effective upon compliance
Calcutta High Court
Where registration was cancelled solely for non-filing of returns for six consecutive months and delay in seeking writ was explained, cancellation was to be set aside on condition that petitioner files all pending returns and pays due tax, interest, fine, penalty and late fees within six weeks
Uttarakhand High Court
Where assessee-firm's GST registration was cancelled solely on ground of filing NIL returns for several months with no additional statutory breach, such action was not permissible under Section 29(2), hence the show-cause notice and cancellation order were quashed as cancellation for filing NIL returns alone is not a valid ground under the statute
Patna High Court
Where registration of works contractor was cancelled for non-filing of returns without affording personal hearing and SCN for revocation lacked officer identity and mandatory DIN, such cancellation and consequent rejection order were invalid, statutory mandate of hearing was not followed, appellate orders suffered from jurisdictional error, so impugned orders were set aside and registration directed to be restored GST: Where petitioner filed updated returns and paid late fee before revocation SCN, but SCN lacked officer name, designation and DIN and did not consider earlier communications regarding illness and son’s murder, such non- application of mind and procedural illegality rendered cancellation, revocation rejection and appellate orders unsustainable and registration was directed to be restored with costs, as later circular could not cure these defects retrospectively
Gauhati High Court
Where petitioners challenged show cause notice for cancellation of GST registration on ground that notice was vague and did not specify statutory provisions or rules allegedly violated, such foundational notice lacking material particulars was unsustainable in law and therefore set aside, without precluding authorities from initiating fresh action as per CGST Act and Rules upon proven infraction
Patna High Court
Where assessee's registration was cancelled based solely on uploading of show cause notice on GST portal without service by e-mail or registered post or personal hearing, portal upload was insufficient for valid service, and settled law required personal service by prescribed modes, making cancellation order invalid and requiring re-issuance of SCN with opportunity for hearing and reasoned decision
Punjab & Haryana High Court
Where petitioner's GST registration was cancelled retrospectively however same was not proposed in show- cause notice, such retrospective cancellation violated natural justice and following settled law, such cancellation was to be quashed with liberty to respondents to proceed afresh as per law
Punjab & Haryana High Court
Where registered person's GST registration was cancelled with retrospective effect from 1 May 2023 though SCN did not propose such retrospective cancellation, such order was not sustainable and had to be quashed in view of relevant precedents, with liberty to authorities to issue fresh SCN and proceed as per law
Telangana High Court
Where registration was cancelled for non-furnishing of returns though SCN alleged fraud, such cancellation was invalid as order rested on a ground not mentioned in SCN, breaching requirement to specify precise grounds with material, therefore SCN and cancellation order were quashed and GST registration was restored, with liberty to issue fresh SCN on proper grounds with supporting documents
Himachal Pradesh High Court
Where order dated 17.01.2025 cancelled registration retrospectively from 15.03.2022 without recording reasons for such retrospectivity in SCN or order, even though material showed no functioning unit at declared premises, retrospective cancellation was to be set aside and petitioner was entitled to a fresh reasoned decision on effective date, with actions post 17.01.2025 remaining intact
Rajasthan High Court
Where petitioner's GST registration was cancelled and statutory appeal was filed with delay of 167 days due to bona fide, uncontrollable reasons including business closure and fraud-tag impacting livelihood, and Appellate Authority otherwise lacked jurisdiction to condone such delay, non-adjudication would cause grave prejudice so delay was condoned and appeal was directed to be entertained on merits
Kerala High Court
Where a registered person amended GST registration to include premises using allegedly fabricated permission letters postdating father’s demise, since alleged fraud related only to amendment and not initial registration, cancelling only the fraudulent amendment while retaining original registration and allowing fresh amendment balanced justice and caused no prejudice to parties
Telangana High Court
Where registered person was issued notice for cancellation of registration citing fraud, bogus invoicing, and not operating from declared place, but the registration was cancelled on unrelated ground of non-filing of six returns without any notice for same, such cancellation was unsustainable as it violated principles of notice and fair hearing, and registration was restored with liberty to respondent to issue fresh SCN
Madras High Court
Where GST registration was cancelled and petitioner sought revival citing precedent in Tvl. Suguna Cutpiece Center v. Appellate Deputy 515 (Madras), impugned cancellation order was to be set aside and writ petition was to be allowed on identical terms
Gauhati High Court
Where partnership firm’s registration was cancelled based on stale show cause notice with no follow-up action for nearly two years and without affording proper or timely hearing, cancellation order was set aside as not conforming to statutory requirements or fairness, but authority may initiate fresh proceedings without excusing compliance obligations of firm
Bombay High Court
Where GST-registered company’s registration was cancelled for non-filing of GSTR-3B despite no allegation of fraud or intentional default, and petitioner undertook to pay all outstanding GST with interest, late fee and penalty, registration was to be restored upon such payment, failing which petition would stand dismissed
Gauhati High Court
Where registration of a rice mill company was cancelled by a non-speaking order based on a show cause notice failing to specify months or relevant period of default, with no reasons recorded for cancellation and without providing an effective opportunity of hearing, such order violated principles of natural justice and thus same was to be held illegal, warranting restoration to show cause notice stage for fresh proceedings in accordance with law
Patna High Court
Where society's registration was cancelled by respondent authority solely on notice uploaded on portal without serving it through other prescribed modes and cancellation order showed procedural error, with State admitting non-service, such action breached mandatory service and natural justice, vitiating cancellation, thus same was to be set aside with liberty to proceed afresh after due compliance with service requirement and opportunity of hearing
Gauhati High Court
GST registration cannot be cancelled for non-filing of returns on basis of a vague show cause notice lacking specific period of return default and absence of reasons;cancellation was to be quashed and matter remanded to show cause stage
Gauhati High Court
Where registration of petitioner providing vehicles on hire was cancelled for non-filing of returns based on a show-cause notice lacking details of default period and an order devoid of specific reasons, such non-speaking cancellation order violated statutory mandate and natural justice, warranting quashing and remand for fresh consideration, as adverse civil consequences necessitate reasoned decision